Today’s the day my wife and I learned that leaving the TV on in the morning while we get dressed for work is leaving quite an impression on our 5-year-old daughter – and we’re going to have to change our morning habits.

You see, for several months, our daughter has wanted a dog for the holidays.  Not a real dog mind you.  But what appears to be the most advanced (and possibly most expensive) digital dog on the market: Fur Real Friends’ My Lovin Pup Biscuit.

Amazon.com
Source: Amazon.com

He’s cute and cuddly and all and, according to the product features listed on Amazon.com, seems like the perfect pet:

  • Playtime is going to the dogs and this playful pooch is leading the charge! The lovable mutt features voice recognition, obeying six commands, including, “Sit”, “Speak”, and “Lie down”
  • Tell your furry friend to give you his paw and he’ll raise his right or left paw ask him if he wants a treat, and he’ll nod and whimper to let you know he’s ready for his dog “bone”
  • Biscuit my lovin’ pup pet will even “shake” at your command, lifting his paw to your hand or sit up and beg, just like a real pup
  • Biscuit my lovin’ pup pet wags his tail and barks, too, to let you know he’s ready to play
  • Use the special adoption certificate to register your pet online and ensure that you and this adorable pup will be friends forever pup pet comes with collar, tag, brush, dog “bone” and adoption certificate

We’ve told her it’s a possibility that she’ll get Biscuit for the holidays, but that s/he’s expensive and we’ll just have to wait and see what happens.  That answer didn’t sit well, as we expected it wouldn’t with most 5-year-olds.  She started volunteering more often for chores to see if she can get a raise on her weekly $1 allowance (she can’t), counting the money in her piggy bank and thinking of all sorts of other ways to get enough money so this dog can be her new pet.

And she noticed she’s coming up short.  That’s where the early morning TV comes into play.  You see, while we’re tuning out the commercials as we get ready for work each day, our daughter isn’t.  She’s listening intently.  In fact, it seems she’s paying more attention to the commercials than the broadcast.

Today, my wife found her sorting through her jewelry box, putting things that looked like gold into one pile and everything else into another.  When pressed on what she was doing, she simply told my wife that she was doing what the man on the TV said to do – she was getting all of my wife’s gold jewelry together so that we could mail it in and get free money that we could use to buy Biscuit.  So clearly, we need to source our morning weather and traffic information from a new source, perhaps the radio.

But more importantly is what to do about Biscuit?  As we debate the merits of buying Biscuit vs. having our daughter continue to work towards contributing financially to it to not buying it at all, I’m wondering, what would YOU do?  Down the road, will our daughter have a bigger life lesson by having played a part in contributing financially to this gift?  Will that take away any of the specialness such holiday gifts often bring?  Or should we completely shelve it as a gift and find ways to make her understand how hard it is to earn more than $100?

10 Comments


  1. I’m sure you were startled by your daughter collecting the jewelry, but I have to say the visual did make me giggle a bit. Don’t ever let her find out about eBay or pawn shops. You’ll come home to an empty house!

    As far as buying biscuit, that’s a tough one. I would probably buy the dog and give it to her as a holiday gift this year (if it’s within your means to do so). With a $1 allowance she will never save enough money to really contribute to the purchase and fractions are sort of lost on 5 year olds. In the meantime, have her continue to save her money and have her buy biscuit an accessory with her funds. Show her that you can work towards purchases, but that sometimes parents get you what you want because you’re a good child.

    Take what I’m saying with a grain of salt because I’m not a parent. I was a child, however, and I wanted A LOT of things. So I get where she’s coming from.


  2. I’m sure you were startled by your daughter collecting the jewelry, but I have to say the visual did make me giggle a bit. Don’t ever let her find out about eBay or pawn shops. You’ll come home to an empty house!

    As far as buying biscuit, that’s a tough one. I would probably buy the dog and give it to her as a holiday gift this year (if it’s within your means to do so). With a $1 allowance she will never save enough money to really contribute to the purchase and fractions are sort of lost on 5 year olds. In the meantime, have her continue to save her money and have her buy biscuit an accessory with her funds. Show her that you can work towards purchases, but that sometimes parents get you what you want because you’re a good child.

    Take what I’m saying with a grain of salt because I’m not a parent. I was a child, however, and I wanted A LOT of things. So I get where she’s coming from.


  3. I vote to buy it for her. It’s Christmas afterall – the season of giving.

    There are 364 other days during the year to teach her life lessons. Let this be her day and make her dreams come true by buying her something she’ll adore.


  4. I vote to buy it for her. It’s Christmas afterall – the season of giving.

    There are 364 other days during the year to teach her life lessons. Let this be her day and make her dreams come true by buying her something she’ll adore.


  5. At $149, this isn’t an insane price for you to buy outright anyway. So I’d suggest you guys ask yourself if she’s honestly learned the lesson that getting stuff is hard and takes work. If she has, and you were planning on buying it anyway, well, seems like lesson learned, reward shown.


  6. At $149, this isn’t an insane price for you to buy outright anyway. So I’d suggest you guys ask yourself if she’s honestly learned the lesson that getting stuff is hard and takes work. If she has, and you were planning on buying it anyway, well, seems like lesson learned, reward shown.


  7. So I read this last night and told Larisa about it today at our event. She had a really good idea.

    Have Santa write her a note that says the elves need some special equipment to make such a special dog and if she could help contribute X amount to the elves he would be able to get it for her.

    That way, she can contribute without having to pay for him totally. I think it could work if she has enough faith in Santa to go for it and that by “holiday” you mean the one that involves Santa 🙂


  8. So I read this last night and told Larisa about it today at our event. She had a really good idea.

    Have Santa write her a note that says the elves need some special equipment to make such a special dog and if she could help contribute X amount to the elves he would be able to get it for her.

    That way, she can contribute without having to pay for him totally. I think it could work if she has enough faith in Santa to go for it and that by “holiday” you mean the one that involves Santa 🙂


  9. That’s a hefty price tag for 1 present. Unless it’s an educational toy I’m a big believer in low tech and letting kids use their imaginations just like we did way back when. You’d be surprised how awesome that can be.


  10. That’s a hefty price tag for 1 present. Unless it’s an educational toy I’m a big believer in low tech and letting kids use their imaginations just like we did way back when. You’d be surprised how awesome that can be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *