10 Comments


  1. Nahhh… I wouldn’t suggest you do that – it’s rather manipulative, imo – but just make sure that YOU are polite 100% of the time. And, sometimes, I ask them “thank you?” to which they reply “oh, yeah, thank you daddy!”

    I will say that others frequently comment on how polite my children are. 🙂


  2. Nahhh… I wouldn’t suggest you do that – it’s rather manipulative, imo – but just make sure that YOU are polite 100% of the time. And, sometimes, I ask them “thank you?” to which they reply “oh, yeah, thank you daddy!”

    I will say that others frequently comment on how polite my children are. 🙂


  3. I’m not sure how maintaining your grasp is any more “manipulative” that verbally reminding a child to say thank you.

    I agree that modeling good manners for kids is always important

    Either way, the end goal is respectful and polite children. Something that we don’t see enough of these days.


  4. I’m not sure how maintaining your grasp is any more “manipulative” that verbally reminding a child to say thank you.

    I agree that modeling good manners for kids is always important

    Either way, the end goal is respectful and polite children. Something that we don’t see enough of these days.


  5. The purpose of doing something like this is to “train” your children, which could be argued is a form of manipulation (which in my book isn’t a bad thing). We’ve trained our kids from word go pretty much, gradually putting more and more emphasis on them listening to what we say and responding accordingly.

    At a certain age you need to start putting stops in place. Whether it’s holding the object to get them to say please, or taking it off them when they don’t, or just talking to them .. You are still training them.


  6. The purpose of doing something like this is to “train” your children, which could be argued is a form of manipulation (which in my book isn’t a bad thing). We’ve trained our kids from word go pretty much, gradually putting more and more emphasis on them listening to what we say and responding accordingly.

    At a certain age you need to start putting stops in place. Whether it’s holding the object to get them to say please, or taking it off them when they don’t, or just talking to them .. You are still training them.


  7. Whatever combination of tactics works to get them to understand that it’s expected behavior… Just make sure that you set the example consistently yourself and call attention to your – and others’ – good manners regularly.


  8. Whatever combination of tactics works to get them to understand that it’s expected behavior… Just make sure that you set the example consistently yourself and call attention to your – and others’ – good manners regularly.


  9. Here’s a random tip: The sign language for “thank you” is trivial. My wife starting teaching our children to say thank you long before they could speak – and the learned it it much more quickly and easier at that age. An un-expected bonus is that we can remind/prompt quietly: no end of times when we would be standing next to another adult who does something nice for a child and we (standing next to or behind the adult) make the thank you sign so that the child sees it and the adult does not. The child often smiles and says thank you and the adult is pleased (and impressed that the child was unprompted) and the child sees that and it re-enforces to the child. It started in our home before the children can speak and has gone a whole lot further than we had hoped.


  10. Here’s a random tip: The sign language for “thank you” is trivial. My wife starting teaching our children to say thank you long before they could speak – and the learned it it much more quickly and easier at that age. An un-expected bonus is that we can remind/prompt quietly: no end of times when we would be standing next to another adult who does something nice for a child and we (standing next to or behind the adult) make the thank you sign so that the child sees it and the adult does not. The child often smiles and says thank you and the adult is pleased (and impressed that the child was unprompted) and the child sees that and it re-enforces to the child. It started in our home before the children can speak and has gone a whole lot further than we had hoped.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *